Dear God, I was at a church service Thursday night (the night before Good Friday), and I got to thinking about The Last Supper. I started to think about the real-time confusion the disciples must have experienced. There were things going on that they had no way of understanding. Jesus was saying things they didn’t understand. They were assuming things would play out in one way, but things were actually on a much different course—a course for which they had no paradigm. So I’ve decided to sit down and try to make a list of everything that happened that evening (as represented in all four Gospels combined), starting with Jesus washing their feet and ending with their walk to the Garden. Here’s what I came up with:
- Jesus washes their feet and asks if they get what He’s teaching them (John 13:4)
- Jesus wants to eat Passover with them before his suffering begins (Luke 22:15)
- One of you will betray me (Matthew 26:21) Jesus says he’s telling them that so that they will no, after the fact, that He is who He says He is (John 13:19)
- Jesus labels Judas as the traitor, but “no one at the meal understood why Jesus said this to him.” (John 13:28)
- Jesus says He is leaving soon and they cannot follow (John 13:33)
- Disciples are troubled because Jesus tries to comfort them: “Do not let your hearts be troubled.” (John 14:1)
- They ask about the way to where Jesus is going. Jesus answers vaguely that He is the way…” (John 14:6)
- Jesus tells them He is sending the Holy Spirit (John 14:16)
- Jesus does some last-minute teaching about being the vine and branches (John 15:1)
- Love one another and ignore hate for them (John 15:17-18)
- Telling them this so they will not go astray (John 16:1)
- Tries to explain Holy Spirit (John 16:5-16)
- The disciples are openly confused and talking among themselves about what He means (John 16:17)
- Jesus prays for Himself (John 17:1)
- Jesus prays for His disciples (John 17:6)
- Jesus prays for all believers (John 17:20)
- Breaks bread as body and wine as blood for sins and covenant (Matthew 26:26-28)
- Jesus will not drink wine again until in Father s Kingdom (Matthew 26:29)
- Disciples argued about who would be greatest in Kingdom (Luke 22:24)
- Everyone will scatter and abandon Jesus (Mark 14:27)
- After raised from the dead Jesus will meet them in Galilee (Mark 14:28)
- Get money, travel bag and a sword (Luke 22:36)
- Peter’s denial predicted (Mark 14:30)
When I went through this exercise I either realized for the first time or remembered some interesting facts about this that I had forgotten. And they are all mainly about John’s version of the story. First, John gives us so much more about the conversation between them that night. There’s a lot of detail there. Second, John’s version of the story is five chapters long (chapters 13-17). Third, John makes zero mention of breaking the bread and pouring the wine. That part of the evening was apparently unimportant to him when compared with the other parts—and yet, as Christians of different denominations, we allow something like how we do communion divide us and count it as of the utmost importance. Are we missing something there? Has Satan used something beautiful as a way to divide us? But I digress.
The real point of all of this is to show that, even when Jesus spoke plainly to them about what was happening (e.g. pointing to Judas as His betrayer), they had no clue. They couldn’t see it. They were about to go through a horrific 72 hours and it seems that they were not prepared for it. Or were they?
Father, at the end of the day, you give us what we need to get through a crisis. It might not look the way we want it to look. It might all go bad. Things might get very dark, and we will need to find our way, moment by moment, with no light. We might be scared, confused, and overwhelmed. We might even feel like giving up. But you call us to press on in the valley of the shadow of death, fearing no evil (Psalm 23:4). And you will give us little remembrances of you and your words. So as my wife and I go through a current confusing time, and as we love some different relatives through their own uncertain times, help us to take your peace with us, embrace the confusion and overwhelmedness (is that a word?), and look forward to what we will have learned from this when it is all over.
In Jesus’ name I pray,
Amen